Lawman (1958)

S4E8 The Catalog Woman

After a newlywed from Laramie goes missing just a day after marrying a woman he found through a marriage catalog, Dan takes it upon himself to investigate. He discovers that other men have also vanished after tying the knot with someone from the same agency. To draw her out, he decides to go undercover as an eligible bachelor named Arthur Daniels. Initially, Lily finds the idea amusing, but her mood shifts to concern and jealousy when Johnny suggests that Dan might be in real danger.