My Babysitter's a Vampire (2011)

S2E4 Flushed

When the water pressure in town suddenly plummets and two teenagers vanish—one from a pool and the other from a school restroom—the gang starts to believe something strange is happening in Whitechapel… or perhaps something alligator-related? Rory reveals that he had flushed two baby alligators during a locker search last year, coinciding with Benny's own potion mishap. After Erica is ambushed at the school car wash, they realize they’re facing not only two furious alligators but also their monstrous mutant offspring. The townspeople of Whitechapel could soon find themselves on the menu!