The Garfield Show (2009)

S1E7 Cat Nap

Garfield and Odie are engrossed in a film featuring a villain called Silent Jack. After watching, they mistakenly think that Jon, who has just had dental surgery, is actually Silent Jack. In a comedic twist, Garfield, Odie, and Squeak realize too late that they’ve been targeting Jon instead of the real villain. As they come to this realization, Silent Jack takes advantage of the situation and robs them, leaving the trio in a hilarious predicament.